Review: Old Limestone Mixing Water

Review: Old Limestone Mixing Water

Review: Old Limestone Mixing WaterIf you’re a huge Scotch nerd, you’ve probably seen the ultimate in geek mixers: Water imported from different regions in Scotland that you’re supposed to add to whisky from that region – the ultimate complement for your high-end hooch.

Now Kentucky’s getting in on the game, with Old Limestone Mixing Water, sourced straight from Bourbon country.

Old Limestone has two selling points. One, it’s limestone-filtered (limestone is everywhere in Kentucky). Two, it’s free of iron. This latter point is often touted by Bourbon makers – and Jack Daniel’s never shuts up about its iron-free water – because it is said to impart negative qualities to Bourbon.

I put Old Limestone side by side with some filtered tap water from my (California) house and, tasting them blind, I couldn’t taste much of a difference, if any. Both were quite neutral, dead flat, with a hint of mineral notes. But then I put a good sized splash into some Bourbon, and damn if I didn’t like the Old Limestone version a bit better. The tap version was fine, but the Old Limestone-doctored whiskey was a little creamier on the palate, with clearer, brighter flavors.

8 bucks for a glass-bottled liter of water might be a bit much (a cheaper, plastic-bottled version is also available), but compared to the price of a premium spirit, it’s really a drop in the bucket, ain’t it?

A- / $8  [BUY IT NOW FROM AMAZON]

Old Limestone Mixing Water

$8
9

Rating

9.0/10

A veteran journalist, the author of four books, a published poet, and an award-winning winemaker, Christopher Null has more than 25 years of experience writing about wine and spirits. He founded Drinkhacker in 2007. He also writes regularly about the science of booze for WIRED and is an occasional contributor to ADI's Distiller magazine. He has been a judge for both the American Distilling Institute Judging of Craft Spirits and Whiskies of the World spirits competitions and often works as a consultant, developing formal tasting notes for spirits brands around the world.

3 Comments

  1. James on December 6, 2015 at 10:02 am

    Mr. Null

    Doesn’t reverse osmosis remove the minerals? If so, doesn’t that make this the same as any other?

    • Christopher Null on December 6, 2015 at 10:25 am

      It would depend on the size of the molecule/particle. Larger particles are filtered out, but smaller ones would remain. That said, I will ask the company for clarification.



  2. brian on December 13, 2022 at 4:57 pm

    can you ice sphere with this water will it come out clear?

Leave a Comment





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.