Review: Old Forester Rye

Old Forester is a little late to the mad rush to rye, but I like to think they were simply taking the time to do it right. No MGP juice here, this is not only made from Old Forester’s homegrown mash, it’s the first new mashbill recipe to come from the brand in 150 years. The full bill is 65% rye, 20% malted barley, and 15% corn. The high proportion of barley in this mash is quite unique. Says Master Distiller and Drinkhacker buddy Chris Morris: “The high proportion of malted barley in this traditional recipe allows for a wholly natural fermentation process, leveraging Old Forester’s proprietary yeast strain. The generous percentage of Malted Barley yields a unique floral character, producing a remarkably balanced Rye.”

There’s no age statement on this whiskey, but note that it is bottled at 50% abv.

We just got our sample bottle, so let’s dig in to taste.

The nose is aggressive, both with barrel char and more intense spice notes, namely cloves, but also black pepper, toasted sesame, and some dried fruit notes. On the palate, the whiskey comes alive, almost immediately. Bold with baking spice notes — heavy on the cloves but spiked with nutmeg and cinnamon — it segues from there into notes of vanilla custard, milk chocolate, and a shaving of lemon peel. The finish is fragrant and lightly sweet with vanilla ice cream and another touch of cinnamon.

Everything works wonderfully well together, with the punchy nose and the more supple palate creating a surprisingly cohesive and complementary whole. The price is also just about perfect, making it an excellent alternative to Rittenhouse should your stock of that essential rye be running low.

As a side note, Old Forester also recommends (of course) pairing the whiskey with its own Old Forester Grandiflora Syrup to make the “perfect” Sazerac, mixed (sans absinthe rinse) over ice in a 4:1 ratio. I tried this out and found it closer to an Old Fashioned than a Sazerac, and the syrup’s included rose petals made it quite a bit too floral for my taste. If you do happen upon some Grandiflora Syrup, try mixing it with the rye in a 6:1 ratio (or even 8:1), which works wonderfully and coaxes a strong chocolate flavor out of the whiskey.

100 proof.


Old Forester Rye




Christopher Null is the founder and editor in chief of Drinkhacker. A veteran writer and journalist, he also operates Null Media, a bespoke content creation company.

1 Comment

  1. Anonymous on November 7, 2019 at 3:20 pm

    Picked up a bottle of this today on the bottom shelf of my local mom-and-pop liquor store. As a longtime Rye aficionado (baby Saz, Rittenhouse bottled in bond and various iterations of Pikesville) this is pretty amazing stuff. The most unexpected note was that of cherry cough drops both on the palate and on the nose… Surprisingly sweet as well as spicy. For the price it’s a no-brainer must try.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.