Review: Buffalo Trace Antique Collection 2011 Edition

Review: Buffalo Trace Antique Collection 2011 Edition

We’ve been writing about Buffalo Trace’s awe-inspiring Antique Collection for longer than I can remember, and each year it seems like these five Bourbons are better than the last time out. This year that streak seems to be taking a breather, with a mixed bag of very good and merely “OK” whiskeys.

I’d still drink any of these in a pinch but, hey, every year can’t be a masterpiece!

Sazerac Rye 18 Years Old 2011 – If you like rye you’re going to love this rendition. Massively intense on the nose, it screams on the palate with heavy middle Eastern spices, toffee, and lacy smokiness. Could use a touch more sweetness to lighten up the finish, but on the whole it’s yet another winner from Sazerac. 90 proof. A- [BUY IT NOW FROM DRIZLY] [BUY IT NOW FROM FROOTBAT]

Eagle Rare Bourbon 17 Years Old 2011 – Actually 18 years, 7 months old. Not much of a nose here, and for a 17-year-old whiskey the palate is on the mild side. If I didn’t know better I’d swear this was a younger spirit, and while the flavor — caramel, vanilla, a touch of chocolate — is there, it lacks the austerity that this whiskey usually brings to the table. 90 proof. B+ [BUY IT NOW FROM DRIZLY]

George T. Stagg Bourbon 2011 – Nobody doesn’t like George Stagg, and this burly monster is again ultra-hot — 142.6 proof — and redolent of deeply charred wood and coffee beans. Bruising and tough, it unfortunately lacks the nuance that prior years of Stagg have brought to the table. The 2011 edition I’m frankly finding tough to crack. The soothing finishing sweetness that usually comes with a solid Stagg release just doesn’t happen here. This makes Drinkhacker sad. 18 years old. B [BUY IT NOW FROM CASKERS] [BUY IT NOW FROM DRIZLY]

William Larue Weller Bourbon 2011 – Smells innocuous, but as with many a Weller of yore, the palate of this wheated Bourbon burns with intense cinnamon notes — almost like red hots candy. Again the finish doesn’t gel the way I’d like, more bitter than bittersweet, and incompletely satisfying. Weller’s never been my favorite of this collection. 133.5 proof, 13 years old. B [BUY IT NOW FROM CASKERS] [BUY IT NOW FROM DRIZLY] [BUY IT NOW FROM FROOTBAT]

Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye 2011 – Curious: The palate is immediately redolent of not grain or wood notes but licorice, making this an oddball installment in the lineup. Fortunately you’ll also find lots of sweet caramel and spicy rye notes here, giving it a lot of flavor. With plenty of heft at 128.8 proof, it doesn’t pull punches, but it’s perhaps a bit too young to really compete with the big boys. (That said, this year perhaps Handy’s youth — 6 years old — is its greatest asset.) B+ [BUY IT NOW FROM DRIZLY] [BUY IT NOW FROM FROOTBAT]


Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye 2011




About Post Author


  1. Chris on October 9, 2011 at 2:22 am

    I have to admit, I’m very surprised by how low the scores are this year. Maybe just an off year for Buffalo Trace? That’d be unfortunate, given how insanely good these whiskies have been in the past.

  2. Matt on October 28, 2011 at 7:47 pm

    I’m confused about what’s going on with the Weller this year. Two different retailers I visited had only 126.6 proof bottles (same proof as last year). Your review and BT’s press release say 133.5. Now I’m curious whether (a) there are somehow multiple proofs out there for this year, (b) if some retailers are getting last year’s bottles, (c) if the press release is wrong, or (d) if the labels are wrong…

  3. Bmac on January 29, 2012 at 9:46 pm

    @Matt – I experienced the same thing. The set had come out and i snagged the Weller only to find that it was last year’s proof. Jim Murray had rated the new Weller 133 proof as a runner up for whiskey of the year. So i figured some of these stores switched bottles so they could the newer weller, for whatever reason. Although this could just be my over active imagination.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.