Review: Scotch Malt Whisky Society Casks 1.152 and 3.160

Review: Scotch Malt Whisky Society Casks 1.152 and 3.160

There are a handful of whiskey clubs out there, but few are as prolific and reputable as the Scotch Malt Whisky Society. The Society has been in operation since 1983 and has bottled over 3,500 casks worth of whisky for its members.

The SMWS, as it’s handily abbreviated, doesn’t just go get bottles off the shelf and send them to you each month, it picks individual casks and bottles its own single malt whiskys sourced from major (and minor) Scotland distilleries.

And it doesn’t tell you what they are.

Bottled at cask strength, these are single cask whiskys, available in very limited quantities (typically under 100 bottles) at prices ranging from $85 and up. Ages can range from 8 to 29 years, and these whiskys come from all over Scotland. In other words: If you buy a whisky from the SMWS, you won’t find that exact same whisky from anyone else.

I’m a little torn on the “blind” identity system – if I’m drinking Macallan, I want to know it’s Macallan – which gives every bottle a code number and a cute name, but lacks the distillery’s ID. But considering the quality of these spirits, based on the two I reviewed below, I’m willing to let it slide. Subcultures exist devoted to figuring out what’s really inside, so dig around if you’re curious. (Update: Since writing this post, these codes have become well publicized.)

Membership is $229, which gets you access to exclusive events like the Whisky Extravaganza, four 100ml bottles of current offerings (pictured below), and a subscription to the society’s magazine – plus, of course, the right to buy whisky from them. Annual dues after the first year drop to $60.

Some thoughts on the whiskys I tasted recently (neither of which are still on the market):

Society Single Cask No. 1.152 – 12 years old, Glenfarclas. Very hot, at a whopping 113.4 proof. Water helps bring out some of the nuance, which includes sweet nougat character, tropical notes, and a little cocoa. Segues into orange, sherry, and marshmallow notes in the end.  The SMWS calls it “Jelly Belly Beans Galore,” which is cute, but doesn’t explain the very lightly peaty finish. Pleasant and curiously fun. A- [BUY IT NOW FROM SMWS]

Society Single Cask No. 3.160 – 10 years old, Bowmore from Islay. Even hotter: 118.8 proof. Be generous with the water. A young whisky, but with charm. Lightly smoky, with burnt nuts and brown sugar notes. Touches of citrus on the finish. B+ [BUY IT NOW FROM SMWS]

Society Single Cask No. 1.152




Christopher Null is the founder and editor in chief of Drinkhacker. A veteran writer and journalist, he also operates Null Media, a bespoke content creation company.


  1. JB on November 4, 2010 at 3:31 pm

    Unfortunately, you have to be at least 25 to join – a requirement that has pained me for a couple years now. I’ll be 23 on Sunday.

  2. Duncs on November 4, 2010 at 8:55 pm

    The lack of identity for the whiskies (beyond whatever name is arbitrarily attributed to them by the SMWS) seems a little frustrating. Perhaps they could have an online database that will allow the drinker to find out what it is they’re tasting if they so wish? If I came across a fantastic whisky I’d be wanting to know the distillery so I could support it by buying its product!

  3. Helen on November 8, 2010 at 9:38 am

    When you think of a distillery’s make you instantly have an expectation in your head – you think of all the characteristics of the ‘brand’. But single casks break all those rules – what may be typical characteristics of the brand or distillery may not come out in a single cask. They are unique and one-of-a-kind (one single cask will be different to the next one, everytime). They break all the conventions of age and region. So don’t be surprised to hear yourself say ‘It tasted nothing like my usual Glenmorangie, this was something else, something wonderful’.

    So how can (and why would) you call it a Glenmorangie when it’s not? Its not about the distillery, its about the cask. And once the contents of that single cask is drunk, you won’t be able to go buy yourself another.

    Explore flavours not brands

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.