Tasting Report: The Tasting Panel Double Gold Winners 2010
Of all the events I attend, The Tasting Panel Magazine’s get-together of its Double Gold Medal winners is the only one that mixes wine with spirits. Nowhere else do I expect to sample a Turkish rose next to peaty Scotch. Somehow it works, and while the selections here were all over the map, some standouts were to be had, including rich Pinot from Jazz Cellars and Sequana, a surprisingly good Pisco (the first time I’ve ever used that phrase) from Pisco “O,” and light, easygoing cachaca from Germana. Notes based on a brief tasting session follow.
Wine
2009 Jules Taylor Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough / $15 / B+ / mild, good for the money
2007 Lynmar Chardonnay Russian River Valley / $30 / B/ huge oak
2009 Kavaklidere Egeo Roze Aegean Turkey / $19 / B+ / tart, curious
2007 De Tierra Pinot Noir Silacci Vineyard Monterey / $32 / B / skunky
2008 Cru-Monterey Pinot Noir Appellation Series Santa Maria Valley / $35 / B- / too herbal, off
2008 Wrath Pinot Noir Quasi Mulla Monterey / $38 / B- / funky notes
2008 Sequana Pinot Noir Sarmento Vineyard Santa Lucia Highlands / $32 / B
2008 Sequana Pinot Noir Dutton Ranch Green Valley / $40 / A-/ solid pinot, authentic
2009 Jazz Cellars Pinot Noir Lone Oak Vineyard Santa Lucia Highlands / $45 / A-/ rich and intense
2006 Paradise View Malbec Sonoma Coast / $32 / A- / surprisingly good for Cal malbec, big herbal finish
2007 Cameron Hughes Cabernet Sauvignon Lot 172 Atlas Peak / $22 / B / hugely tannic
2007 Halter Ranch Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles / $28 / B-
2007 Millarium Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley / $75 / A-/ rich, has aging potential
2007 Valley of the Moon Cabernet Bland, Cuvee de la Luna Sonoma County / $30 / B
2007 St Helena Road Winery-Maier Family Meritage Sonoma / $34 / B
2007 Niner Wine Estates Fog Catcher Paso Robles / $58 / B+ / rich blackberry notes
2006 J. Lohr Cuvee Pau, Paso Robles / $50 / B- / overdone
NV Gonzalez Byass Oloroso Sherry Solera 1847 Superior Selection / $18 / B+
Spirits
Rokk Vodka, Sweden / $NA / B+ / traditional, light sweetness
Pisco “O” Torontel, Ica, Peru / A- / $35 / intense lemon notes, a surprise
2009 Germana SOUL Cachaca, Brazil / A- / $29 / light and easy
Germana Tradicional Cachaca, Brazil / B+ / $34 / bolder, lightly aged
2009 Germana Heritage Cachaca, Brazil / B / $79 / even more aged, but unbalanced
Tequila Blu Reposado, Mexico / B / $38 / a tough rough
Tequila Cinco Blancos Anejo, Mexico / B- / $23 / rough attack, harsh
El Zacatecano Anejo Mescal, Mexico / B+ / $NA / almost no smoke – this is mescal?
Rum Vizcaya VXOP Solera Rum, Dominican Republic / B+ / $38 / overwhelming sweetness
Isle of Jura Single Malt Scotch, Prophecy, Scotland / B+ / $70 / massive peat bomb, big iodine notes
Pere Magloire Calvados VSOP, France / B- / $40 / tough and rough
Pere Magloire Calvados XO, France / B+ / $75 / huge apple character (as one would hope)
Comandon Cognac XO, France / B+ / $145 / tasty, but needs better balance, off finish
Thanks for the kind words on the Sequana. Glad you liked it. The 2008s are still pretty young, we think they’ll be even better after another year.
David Shabelman
Sequana Vineyards
I have Germana “Soul” here and it’s great. A gift from the in-laws.