Review: Templeton Rye (2009)


If they were drinking whiskey this good back in the Prohibition days, I don’t feel so bad for them after all. Templeton was a purported favorite of Al Capone and “the center of his bootlegging empire,” Templeton Rye is a killer whiskey that — if marketing is to be believed — has been being produced in small quantities ever since those dark days. (Update: Turns out it’s made by MGP in Indiana and the “Prohibition era recipe” is bullshit.)

Templeton is less overtly spicy than many ryes, and I found it to have more of a Canadian whisky character to it (which is typically a blend of rye and other grain whiskeys). Reportedly aged for five years in charred oak (though no formal age statement is noted), this is a surprisingly deep brown whiskey for a rye.

The flavor profile is overwhelming, and in a good way. Starting with honeycomb and toffee, it soon reveals notes of buttermilk biscuits, shortbread, and even gingersnaps. Extremely easygoing, there’s virtually no heat on the finish at all, which is probably why I’m well into glass #3. A bit of dark chocolate plays on the finish, too.

What’s not to like? Pretty much nothing except it’s horrible lack of availability. The whiskey was available only in Iowa until 2007. Now it’s creeping across the country, city by city.

Update: This is now bottled with a 4 Year Old age statement.

80 proof.


Templeton Rye (2009)




Christopher Null is the founder and editor in chief of Drinkhacker. A veteran writer and journalist, he also operates Null Media, a bespoke content creation company.


  1. Edoc on March 23, 2009 at 6:11 am

    I ordered a bottle online from Binnys. I hope it’s not back-ordered.

  2. Christopher Null on March 23, 2009 at 9:52 am

    Have yet to encounter High West.

  3. augustgarage on March 23, 2009 at 9:25 am

    Have you compared this to High West Rendezvous Whiskey? It is rumored that both bottlers may have sourced their whiskey from a former Seagram’s production facility in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, who shipped rye to Canada for blending.

    Both High West and Templeton started bottling before they started distilling (I’m not sure High West have actually started distilling yet) – so, marketing aside, the liquid in the bottle is not likely to have been produced in Iowa.

  4. Edoc on March 25, 2009 at 3:10 pm

    Received my bottle today. A few sips into my first glass, I’m impressed by how drinkable this is. Has a faint sweetness to it. You’re exactly right about there being virtually no heat on the finish.

  5. Edoc on March 27, 2009 at 6:34 pm

    I’m not that acquainted with rye whiskey, so I can’t compare this to other brands. However, this is so balanced and has so much candy and caramel on the nose that it reminds me a little of one of the friendliest rums on the market, Angostura 1919.

  6. Edoc on March 30, 2009 at 7:45 am

    For my birthday, a friend gave me a bottle of Hudson Manhattan rye whiskey, pictured here:

    It’s a bit pricey at $35 for 375 Ml, but the nose is even more concentrated than the Templeton Rye. Highly recommended.

  7. CincyCapell on May 12, 2009 at 12:12 am

    Overpriced for a whiskey that is only 80 proof, frankly. Is this indeed straight Rye, or is this a blended whiskey? Contrary to what your article suggests, Canadian blended whiskey only contains a very small portion of rye. The whiskey is then blended with pure grain alcohol (vodka, essentially.). This sounds like over-priced Canadian Club.

  8. Christopher Null on May 12, 2009 at 8:50 pm

    CincyCapell – I think it’s a mistake to evaluate a whiskey based solely on its proof; for many distillers, they release the spirit at the proof where it shows the best. I love cask strength stuff too, but standard proof expressions can be just as engaging and complex. As for the portion of rye here’s what Templeton’s PR says: “I spoke with the president of TR (Scott Bush). As you probably know, by law a rye has to be at least 51% rye in the mash bill. TR is not 100% rye but are much higher than most ryes on the market. They do not share their exact mash bill.” — and as for Canadian’s rye content, you’re right; it’s not typically that high in rye (10-25% is common), but for many Canadian whiskys, the rye is the place where they get the bulk of their character.

  9. Ryan on November 24, 2009 at 9:28 am

    Sampled with with the sales rep this last weekend and bought a bottle. I believe he said the legal definition of Rye was 51%+ Rye, and they use about 90% Rye.

    As reported here, very nice, smooth…easily sippable. VERY nice.

    I’m in ChicagoLand, so it’s being distributed this far. I believe the rep said they were distributing it to Iowa and Illinois as of 11/2009. He mentioned something about ramping up production to support wider distribution…with a 5 year lead time, it will take awhile. Keep in mind they have only been in business since 2001.

    On a fun side note, the rep as well as the company elders are in the picture on the bottle.

  10. Bill on December 8, 2009 at 4:41 pm

    I had a small tasting party with templeton, overholt, saranac, rittenhouse (80 and 100 proof), russel’s and beam and the favorite was rittenhouse. Templeton, saran overholt and russel’s followed in order.

    It was ALL good, though… and by the end of the night was very good.

  11. Patrick on July 17, 2013 at 2:24 pm

    to me, templeton rye smells overwhelmingly of caramelized bananas upon first whiff. it does go down a treat, though. our local costco has pallets of it for $32/bottle right now. makes a good manhattan, too.

  12. ay dee jay on February 10, 2015 at 12:20 am

    As we later learn, Templeton, Bulleit Rye, and High West are all sourced from MGP in Lawrenceburg Indiana. It sounds like Hudson is mash / fermented / distilled locally. Agreed that there is more to it than just the fact that some producers / bottlers use the same source, and I have tried them all and find them enjoyable but was not surprised to learn that they might be share the same origin, even if they are varying blends of different mash bills. And the same goes for Dickel Rye too – last I heard it was MGP. Not sure about about the Jim Beam / Old Overholt / Knob Creek rye trinity or Wild Turkey Rye but I like them all near equally.

    • Christopher Null on February 10, 2015 at 8:06 am

      Dickel Rye is also MGP, yes. We have a review of it on the site too.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.