Monthly Archives: November 2011

Tasting Report: Bonhams Pre-Auction Event October 2011

Apologies for how long it’s taken me to get around to typing up my notes on the latest tasting from the auctioneers at Bonhams, but hey, these wines aren’t going anywhere. The most recent event featured a quintet of Champagnes, lots of old French Burgundy and Bordeaux, and finished up with some interesting New World Pinot Noir. If only I had been able to bid on that 1996 Nuits St. George — easily my favorite wine of the event.

Tasting Report: Bonhams Pre-Auction Event, October 2011

NV Krug Grande Cuvee / B+ /

NV Lamandier-Bernier Blanc de Blanc / B /

NV Alain Soutiran Blanc de Noir “Perle Noir” / A- / tropical, big

1997 Jacquesson Extra Brut / A- /

NV Pierre Peters Brut / A- / lighter

1997 Puligny Montrachet Les Pucelles J.M. Boillot / C+ / way past its prime

2003 Bienvenue Batard Montrachet Domaine Leflaive / B / lightly corked, but I thought the fruit was still there

2004 Corton Charlemagne Chandon de Briailles / B+ / tart, acidic and yeasty

2003 Marcassin Chardonnay Three Sisters Vineyard / B+ / off finish

2001 Braunberger Juffer Sonnenuhr Riesling Kabinett F. Haag / A / brisk

2002 JF Coche-Dury Meursault Les Chevaliers / B+ / curious, lean

1996 Les Perrieres R. Chevillon Nuits St. Georges / A / great life to it

1998 Les Hauts Doix R. Groffier Chambolle Musigny / A- / lighter

2001 Taupenot-Merme Mazoyeres Chambertin / A- / bit thin

2002 Domain de la Romanee-Conti Echezeaux / A- /

2005 V. Girardin Vosne Romanee Vieille Vignes / A- /

1999 Chateau Trotanoy Pomerol / A- / earthy, good balance

2000 Chateau Pichon-Lalande Pauillac / B+ / big

2003 Chateau Pichon Baron Pauillac / B / bit pruny

2001 Poggio Antico Brunello di Montalcino Riserva / A- /

1999 Vina Sastre Ribera del Duero Pago de Santa Cruz / A- / huge wine, will last for years

1993 Conterno Monfortino Barolo Riserva / B+ / fading

1992 Domaine Tempier Bandol Cuvee Speciale La Tourtine / A- / substantial

1995 Chapoutier Hermitage La Sizeranne / A- / fading

2005 Champet Cote Rotie La Viaillere / A- / heavy with meat character

2006 Vieux Telegraph Chateauneuf-du-Pape / A- /

1999 Clarendon Hills Syrah “Moritz” / B- / big and clunky

2003 Standish Shiraz “The Standish” / B / overjammed

2004 Ken Wright Pinot Noir Wahle Vineyard / A- / black cherry, earth, licorice

2006 Brewer-Clifton Pinot Noir Mount Carmel Vineyard / A- / quite light

1994 Silver Oak Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon / B / punchy, mamoth

2003 Peter Michael Cabernet Sauvignon “Les Pavots” / A- / good balance

2004 Woodward Canyon Cabernet Sauvignon Old Vines / A- / good balance

2004 Bryant Family Cabernet Sauvignon / B+ / too big

Review: Kansas Spirit Whiskey

You’re not in Kansas any more, Dorothy. Oh, wait, you are in Kansas, drinking Kansas whiskey.

Fittingly called Kansas Clean Distilled Spirit Whiskey, this new brand from the newly-formed Fabulous American Beverages company (no, that’s the company’s name), is unconventional in just about every way. For starters, it’s from Kansas, not Kentucky, and it’s distilled in a column still, entirely from winter wheat, not corn. That alone isn’t that eyebrow-raising. Column stills are used everywhere in Kentucky, and 100% wheat whiskeys, while rare, exist. So far, so good.

But the inspiration for Kansas, per the company, is vodka, and the final product is meant to appeal to a younger club crowd instead of, well — as the advertising puts it — old dudes. After this distillation, this spirit is mixed with other (presumably aged) whiskey, and the final product — which does not appear to be aged further — is bottled.

Kansas has a very pale yellow color that looks more like a lightly aged tequila than a whiskey. The nose and body are something else altogether. Take a whiff and you get not wood and smoke but candy. Marshmallows and cotton candy, extremely sweet. And I hardly ever use italics. It literally pours out of the glass as you smell it, it’s that strong. Long finish, and not unpleasant, just bracing in its sweetness. Calling it “smooth” is a serious understatement.

Kansas may connote the heartland, but the whiskey comes across more like a flavored vodka. In fact, that may technically be what it is. After all, many a vodka is distilled from wheat in a column still. If it isn’t aged directly, is it whiskey? Even if some whiskey goes into it?

I’m a bit baffled as to what exactly to make of Kansas. As “whiskey” it’s a disaster, completely without any of the character that makes real whiskey so distinctive. Maybe I’m the “old guy” now, after all.

But as a vodka alternative it’s actually pretty intriguing, with lots of character that you don’t usually get in the vodkaverse. Whiskey-flavored vodka? That’s not far from the mark. I’m not sure that’s a good thing for the spirits world, but what can you do? Now it’s here.

I also have little idea what to do by way of a rating. Here’s my best attempt.

80 proof.

B / $30 / kansascleandistilled.com

UPDATE: Kansas Owner Paul Goldman responds:

Christopher,

Thank you for taking the time to review Kansas. Your palate doesn’t quite agree with the people who love our whiskey. That’s okay with us. However your readers may wish get a few facts straight so that they might have a better understanding of what Kansas Whiskey is all about.

You write that Kansas may be technically, a vodka.  I hope you were not attempting here to disparage our brand and that you were just misinformed in your assertion. Actually technically, Kansas is, and can only be a whiskey as defined by the US TTB, the US government body that establishes strict guidelines as to what a spirit, of any category may claim to be.  Spirit whiskey is one of a number of categories of whiskey, like bourbon whiskey, scotch whiskey, straight whiskey, Irish whiskey etc. Many whiskies contain various blends of neutral spirit. Other whiskies distill some percentages of one grain mash at a higher level to supply the alcohol content and leave their other grains at a lower alcohol content to define flavor. Despite the various methods of distillation we’re all still whiskies. 

You suggest that you’re “..a bit baffled of what to make of Kansas. As a whiskey it’s a disaster.” We’ll take “baffled” as a compliment actually. We’re new, we’re a category of whiskey that is entirely unchartered and we deliver an experience–to some like yourself, that is curious. 

But to suggest its a disaster is just a weird thing to say.  Disaster as what? A bourbon? A Rye? Scotch? Surely you’d never compare a single malt to the ryes you love. Or an Irish to a port finished bourbon. I’m curious as to the context in which you’re comparing our whiskey. If you’ve not had another Spirit Whiskey against which to compare Kansas then you’re not in a position to make such a claim. Such a description without context appears careless and vaguely spiteful for some reason. 

Your readers might wish to also know that while you perceive Kansas as being sweeter than other whiskies, Kansas actually has a Brix degree, (sugar content) less than many whiskies we tested. By removing nearly all the congeners inherent in most whiskies–resulting in the smoothness you recognized,  Kansas is left without the harshness found in other whiskies. Your palate may possibly perceive that lack of intervening harshness as being “Sweeter”. 

Finally and on a personal note, I believe you were in receipt of our marketing materials. Indeed our marketing makes fun of the stodginess of the entire category of other whiskies. It should. Apart from a recent surge in Irish whiskey, (the result of a considerable spend), Whiskey is flat in sales and has been for 40 years. This has nothing to do with the delicious varieties of available whiskies and everything to do with their marketing people tripping behind their brands.  Its not the liquid’s fault that we see whiskey associated with old things, old labels old style bottles –which keeps the audience for whiskey firmly planted in middle aged men. 

But none of the observations we make, which make fun of competitor’s advertising and marketing of whiskey have anything to do with reviewers like yourself. That’s nuts. If you love whiskey, it doesn’t mean your old. It just means you’re in love. 

Our goal is spread that love just a little bit more.

Thanks again for your time, we just want to make sure everyone gets the facts straight.  

Best,

Paul Goldman
Owner, Kansas Clean Distilled Spirit Whiskey

kansas spirit whiskey Review: Kansas Spirit Whiskey

Review: Founders CBS (Canadian Breakfast Stout)

Nothing quite signifies the change of seasons so strikingly as the tendency for breweries to release thicker and heavier beers in the colder months. It therefore seems fitting that Michigan-based Founders chose this time to release its Canadian Breakfast Stout, or CBS as it is affectionately abbreviated on the bottle. Formerly a draft-only offering, this release marks the first time CBS has been commercially bottled and is the third entry into the “Breakfast Stout” line, alongside Founders Breakfast Stout and Kentucky Breakfast Stout, which is aged in bourbon barrels. CBS takes this progression even further by filling these bourbon casks with maple syrup, and after letting it impart its flavor to the wood, drains them and fills them with the beer. What we are left with is a 10.6% abv imperial stout which is brewed with chocolate and coffee and absorbs the bourbon and maple notes from the barrels in which it was aged.

Straight out of the bottle, the liquid looks exactly as I was expecting; thick, ebony, almost sticky. A mocha-colored and frothy head helps open the bouquet, which delivers that same bold espresso note that is so prominently featured in the other Breakfast Stout beers. Likewise, the bourbon is rich and sweet to help cut this roast and is aided by the chocolate. The biggest surprise is the apparent lack of maple syrup, which should be the calling card for this beer. I’m not sure if it’s the more robust characteristics of the beer overshadowing the maple, but it’s faint and only comes in around the finish. In the taste, the maple shines more so than in the nose, but I can’t help but say I would’ve wanted more. The full body is spot on for the style and huge flavors, with active carbonation to keep it from getting too heavy.

I haven’t tried this on tap, so this is my first exposure to the famed CBS, and I have to say it has lived up to my expectations. The adjectives that immediately come to mind are ones of high praise, from decadent to gourmet. The only fault I can levy against it is the somewhat muffled maple syrup characteristic, but it improves in the flavor. These bottles sold out quickly, so it may be difficult to come across one, but definitely seek one out if you can!

A / $25 per 750ml bottle / foundersbrewing.com

Founders CBS Review: Founders CBS (Canadian Breakfast Stout)

Review: Firefly Mint Tea Vodka

“Messing with a classic” is always a danger, and Firefly‘s mint-flavored version of its classic Sweet Tea Vodka is indeed a bit of a distraction from what makes this vodka stand out.

The tea character is certainly there, as is a healthy slug of mint. But while that tea remains authentic and smooth, the mint is rough and a bit artificial tasting. This comes across most clearly in the finish, which goes out not with a tapered coda but with an almost harsh sharpness, its touch of Altoids leaving you not ready for sip two but begging instead for an extra splash of water.

Hardly bad — the mint is downplayed in comparison to the tea, on the whole — it’s still not nearly the masterwork its big brother is.

B+ / $18 / fireflyvodka.com

Firefly Mint tea vodka Review: Firefly Mint Tea Vodka

Thanksgiving Cocktails from Skyy Spirits

This Thursday you can stuff your face the old-fashioned way, or you can go boozy. These five concoctions come from our friends at Skyy Spirits — I’m not sure if you want to try for all five this Thursday, but a couple of alcoholic twists on the Thanksgiving feast aren’t going to kill anyone…

Cocktail Hour: We start things off with a classic for cocktail hour. This year, we are thankful for the Negroni and all its variations. The Boulevardier, an American twist of Italian classic, prepares the palate for the Thanksgiving feast ahead.

The Boulevardier

3/4 oz. Campari
3/4 oz. Sweet Vermouth
1 1/2 oz. Wild Turkey 81 Bourbon

Stir with ice, and strain into a chilled 5 1/2 oz. coupe. Garnish with an orange (or lemon) twist.

Sides: No Thanksgiving is complete without the sides! Cranberry and sweet potatoes are particularly suited to cocktail versions. Aren’t you glad we didn’t try to make a cocktail with stuffing or green bean casserole? We might be creative, but we’re not crazy. For mashed potatoes, we direct you to the classic Old Potato Cocktail, which is 1 oz Apple Jack (another American classic), 1 oz Dry Vermouth, 2 oz Irish Whiskey.

Turkey’s Best Friend

Created by Master Sommelier Fred Dexheimer
1.5 oz Wild Turkey 81
2 oz apple cider
1 Tbsp cranberry jelly
1 sprig fresh sage
1 sprig fresh thyme

Muddle sage and thyme with apple cider. Add ice, top with Wild Turkey and cranberry jelly. Shake well, strain over ice in a glass rimmed with turkey jus and breadcrumbs.

Sweet Potato Pie Eyed 237x300 Thanksgiving Cocktails from Skyy SpiritsSweet Potato Pie-Eyed

1 ½ oz Skyy Infusions Blood Orange Vodka
½ oz Irish Mist
1 oz fresh lime juice
¼ oz maple syrup
¼ oz molasses
1 tbsp roasted or mashed sweet potato

In a cocktail shaker, combine syrup, molasses and sweet potato. Muddle gently. Add ice and the remaining ingredients. Shake vigorously and strain into a glass. Garnish with a sage leaf and garnish.

The Bird: We promise this bird won’t be dry! Thanksgiving 101 is the quintessential classic American cocktail that ridiculously easy to prepare. All you need is a bottle of Wild Turkey 101 and a punch bowl. We provide mixers, such as cola, ginger ale, and soda water for guests to customize their own drinks. Thanksgiving-seasonal garnishes, such as cranberries, rosemary, sage, and cinnamon sticks help add that festive touch. A no-fuss salute to the “American spirit.”

Thanksgiving 101 (a bit of a punt on this one, folks!)

Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon
Ice
Punch Bowl

Dessert: Finishing off our Thanksgiving feast is a pumpkin pie, of course. Thankfully, there is no word yet of a pumpkin pie filling shortage this year. Where would we be without pie? Guess we’d all be eating cake.

Pumpkin Smash 223x300 Thanksgiving Cocktails from Skyy SpiritsPumpkin Smash

1 ¼ oz Frangelico
1 ¼ oz Flor de Caña 7 Year Grand Reserve
¾ oz pumpkin purée

Shake hard with ice and strain out into a semi martini glass or small rocks glass. Garnish sprinkle of ground clove or nutmeg. Serve in a martini glass.

Tasting Report: Wines of Mendocino

The weather’s been surprisingly delightful in Mendocino this fall, and a recent excursion to the coast brought not fog and drizzle but sunshine, warmth, and sea breezes. We took the opportunity to visit a number of wineries along the Mendo wine trail, finding some new Anderson Valley favorites in Phillips Hill’s lush Pinot Noirs, squirreled away in a quiet tasting room in the tiny town of Philo. Thoughts on other wines from this land of Pinot, unoaked Chardonnay, and a healthy number of German varietals follow.

2011 Mendocino Road Trip Tasting Notes

2009 Navarro Pinot Gris / $19 / B /

2009 Navarro Gewurztraminer / $19 / B /

2010 Navarro Riesling / $18 / B- /

2010 Navarro Edelzwicker / $13 / A- / my fave wine from Navarro, a lovely German style belnd

2009 Navarro Navarouge / $14 / B / licorice notes

2009 Navarro Pinot Noir / $19 / B / very dry

2007 Navarro Pinot Noir Methode a l’Ancienne / $29 / B+ /

2006 Navarro Cabernet Sauvignon / $29 / B / licorice again

2009 Navarro Gewurztraminer Late Harvest / $35 / A- / like peach pie

2006 Navarro Riesling Cluster Select Late Harvest (375ml) / $29 / B+ / honey and tea

2005 Scharfenberger Blanc de Blancs / $30 / B / big, yeasty

NV Scharfenberger Brut / $20 / B+ / more fruit, light bitterness on finish

NV Scharfenberger Rose / $25 / B+ / blackberry notes

NV Scharfenberger Extra Dry / $21 / B+ / light sweetness is nice

NV Scharfenberger Cremant / $25 / B- / cheesy character

2006 Scharfenberger Pinot Noir / $20 / B / past its prime

2007 Scharfenberger Syrah / $23 / A- / chewy, good fruit

2008 Scharfenberger Chardonnay / $16 / B+ / easy

NV Roederer Brut / $20 / A- / lots of fruit

NV Roederer Brut Rose / $27 / A- / lovely strawberry

2002 Roederer L’Ermitage Brut / $43 / B / tart, acidic and yeasty

2000 Roederer L’Ermitage Brut (magnum) / $90 / A / considerably better, creamy and balanaced

NV Roederer Extra Dry / $22 / A- / sweet finish, nice

2009 Roederer Rose of Pinot / $19 / B /

2007 Roederer Pinot Noir / $22 / B+ /

2008 Roederer Chardonnay / $18 / B /

2009 Goldeneye Chardonnay Migration / $30 / A- / figs and lemon

2009 Goldeneye Anderson Valley Pinot Noir / $55 / A- / herbs and mint, easygoing

2009 Goldeneye Anderson Valley Pinot Noir Confluence Vineyard / $75 / A- / light body, quite similar to the blend

2009 Goldeneye Anderson Valley Pinot Noir Gowan Creek Vineyard / $75 / B+ / tougher, great with cheese

2009 Goldeneye Anderson Valley Pinot Noir The Narrows Vineyard / $75 / B+ / a bit unripe and heavy, needs time

2010 Phillips Hill Chardonnay / $30 / A- /

2010 Phillips Hill Gewurztraminer Valley Foothills / $18 / B+ / unusual, big acid and earth

2009 Phillips Hill Pinot Noir Wiley Vineyard / $38 / A / great fruit here, Burgundy style earth

2009 Phillips Hill Pinot Noir Boontling / $27 / B / some bitterness, tougher

2008 Phillips Hill Pinot Noir Beeson Tree / $40 / B+ / from the Mendocino fire year, hugely smoky, like a Syrah

2008 Phillips Hill Pinot Noir Oppenlander Vineyard / $38 / A- / mushrooms, good earth, nice fruit too

Review: Smirnoff Whipped Cream and Fluffed Marshmallow Vodkas

OK, we’re fully into goofball territory now. Smirnoff’s latest flavors are full-on panty peeler, no bones about it, loaded with sugar, certainly full of artificial flavors, and dialed back to 60 proof so you can’t taste the alcohol. At all.

Smirnoff Whipped Cream Vodka – Sure, I’ll buy that. It’s more caramelized sugar than whipped cream. Baked Alaska or crispy creme brulee crust, with a distinct coconut vibe, instead of Reddy Whip. That said, it’s so sweet that any sense of “vodka” all but vanishes into the dessert course here. Add to coffee, hot chocolate, or your insulin shot. B

Smirnoff Fluffed Marshmallow Vodka – Are we done? We are not done. Because while I’ve tried whipped cream vodkas before, here comes the first marshmallow-flavored vodka I’ve ever tried. Fluffed isn’t right: Like the Whipped Cream version, there’s a burnt character here. This is toasted marshmallow, not fluffed marshmallow. I swear you can taste the stick that’s impaling the marshmallow and holding it over the campfire. I think this is a little more complex, and ultimately a bit more interesting — for a crazy girl drink vodka, anyway. B+

$14 each / smirnoff.com

Review: Bruichladdich Laddie Classic, Organic, Port Charlotte An Turas Mor, and Octomore 3

Islay’s Bruichladdich — “the progressive Hebridean distillers” — is in the midst of an upheaval. Long known for releasing dozens of whiskys each year, the distillery has suffered from a bit of an identity crisis. Some Bruichladdich whiskys could be light and filled with fruit. Some are overwhelming peat bombs. Where is the distillery’s soul?

Finally, Bruichladdich has had a crisis of conscience and is refocusing on fewer brands, splitting them among natural divisions. Going forward, the Bruichladdich brand will focus on unpeated whiskys. The Port Charlotte and Octomore brands will feature peated stuff. Overall, the number of bottlings (or SKUs) will greatly decrease. By my count we’ll see roughly six new bottlings (instead of 16) from Bruichladdich this season.

We tasted the four major releases from the company coming down the pipeline.

Bruichladdich Laddie Classic Edition 01 – This “minimally peated” dram will be part of the “core” offerings from Bruichladdich going forward, a vatting of old (18-20 year old whiskeys and younger (5-7 year old) stuff, aged fully in ex-Bourbon casks. A really solid and, indeed, classic whisky. Mild honey and nougat on the nose, masking what turns into a surprisingly big body, with burnt sugar, orange, and toffee. Wood kicks in on the finish. Nice balance of sweetness with the savory finish, and the lush creaminess gives it a certain austerity you don’t often find in mid-level whiskys. While not cheap, it’s still a great candidate for an “everyday dram.” 92 proof. A- / $69

Bruichladdich The Organic – This is a vatting of three prior Bruichladdich Organic releases: Organic 2003, 2004, and 2005. Now just called “The Organic,” it’s still a collection of whiskys made from organic barley. I don’t like the nose on this one. It’s funky, with a kind of mushroomy character to it. The body is an improvement, hefty straw and grain notes — this is, after all, designed to showcase what barley tastes like — but its youth gets in the way. A curious novelty, but I’m not loving it at this price. 92 proof. B- / $78

Bruichladdich Port Charlotte An Turas Mor – Another vatting, this is a blend of Port Charlotte PC6, PC7, and PC8. Heavily peated, the nose is something like sweet barbeque smoke, fruity and a bit like a sugary bacon. The body is a bit on the thin side, and the finish isn’t entirely balanced. A whisky this peaty needs more body to back it up. 92 proof. B / $72

Bruichladdich Octomore 3 – Now officially the most heavily peated whisky on earth: A stunning 152ppm of phenol. (Where will it end? Who knows.) Aged 5 years. Those of you who’ve experienced these ultra-peated whiskys know the score, but I found this third round of Octomore more engaging and, surprisingly, easier going than earlier versions. Yes, the smoke and heat are devastating, but they are tempered with something almost candy-like. This isn’t a Scotch for everyone, but it’s easily worth a sample if you’re a smoldering type. 18,000 bottles made. 118 proof. A- / $195

bruichladdich.com

“Chasing Pappy” Seeks Whiskey, Funding

Pappy Van Winkle is one of the most legendary brands in Bourbon today… so why not make a movie about the whiskey’s fans, who often have to hunt high and low to find the Bourbon they love so much? That’s what Mark Casey is up to, and he’s trying to raise $3,000 to get his movie (a short subject documentary) made. I’m kicking in a few bucks on Kickstarter to help… how about you?

Review: 2011 Georges Duboeuf Beaujolais Nouveau

I don’t know where the rule is written that Beaujolais Nouveau labels have to be more garish each year, but Duboeuf is doing its best to follow that rule to the letter. 2011′s labels aren’t quite horrific, but they’re getting there. The good news, of course, is that they’ll be gone by the time New Year’s rolls around.

We tasted both of the 2011 releases, which are officially hitting the market tonight.

2011 Georges Duboeuf Beaujolais Nouveau – Exceptionally pruny, with a thin body. The finish is underwhelming, funky. Very similar to the candy-coated 2010. C+ / $10

2011 Georges Duboeuf Beaujolais-Villages Nouveau – A modest improvement, with a (very welcome) bigger body and more of a sense of balance. Still, it’s overwhelming in the jammy fruit department. This year it’s more cherry than strawberry, but it still has a ways to go toward hitting true drinkability. That said, it’s fun to try once a year, though. B- / $12

duboeuf.com

Georges Duboeuf Beaujolais Nouveau 2011 Bottle Shot Review: 2011 Georges Duboeuf Beaujolais Nouveau